PLATFORMS

SEO by platform: they all rank, they all carry debt

The industry has spent years repeating a list of good guys and bad guys. WordPress is the good one. You can't do anything with Wix. Shopify ties your hands. Most of that was true ten years ago.

Wix carries its reputation from the days of Flash and hashbang URLs. Today it has server-side rendering, customisable structured data, per-page control of indexation and metadata, and a redirect manager. It ranks. With a ceiling, but it ranks. And more than one Wix project has landed here where the only thing missing was someone looking at it properly.

So the useful question isn't which platform is best. It's what you'll have to fix on yours before SEO starts paying off. Because they all have something, and in each one it's always the same thing.

What to fix on each platform

This is what we find when a new project comes in, depending on what it arrives on.

Platform What it does well Its technical debt Suits
WordPress Total control: server, code, robots.txt. There's nothing you can't touch Performance. Heavy themes and years of accumulated plugins sink Core Web Vitals Content and corporate sites where the blog leads
WooCommerce The same control as WordPress, with ecommerce on top Scale. As the catalogue grows, facets and crawl budget get out of hand Mid-sized catalogues already living on WordPress
Shopify Fast out of the box and hard to break. The basics come solved Every product lives at two URLs. The canonical points correctly by default, but theme links split the signals. Fixable in Liquid Anyone who'd rather not think about infrastructure
Prestashop Multi-language and multi-country natively, no plugins needed Performance if nobody optimises it, and third-party modules of wildly varying quality European retail across several markets
Magento Huge catalogues and segmented B2B pricing without breaking a sweat The real cost. It needs infrastructure and dedicated people; it doesn't run itself Enterprise with a large catalogue and a budget to match
Wix Technical basics solved without touching anything. Per-page control of metadata, indexation and redirects A closed platform: you don't control the code or how the page is served. The ceiling shows up in fine-grained performance Local businesses and service sites in less contested niches

Notice that none of that debt stops you ranking. All of it costs work before you start, and the work is different in each case.

And the worst thing about this debt is that it doesn't look like debt. The shop loads, the products show, the sales come in. Nothing is broken. You're simply splitting between two URLs the strength that should go to one, and that doesn't appear in any report until somebody audits it.

It's the difference between a specialist who lands on your Shopify and starts writing content, and one who checks the canonicals first. The first is building on a leak. You notice at six months, when traffic hasn't moved and nobody knows why.

Do you know what debt your platform carries? We'll tell you on the first call, free.

Request a diagnosis

What actually decides it

If you're choosing a platform, three questions matter more than the brand.

How much are you going to grow?

A 500-product catalogue fits anywhere. A 50,000 one doesn't. The point where a platform starts to hurt is volume, not the logo.

How much competition do you have?

In a quiet niche the platform is irrelevant: whoever has the better content wins. In banking, insurance or consumer goods, where every tenth of a Core Web Vitals point counts, the ceiling of a closed platform does show.

Who's going to maintain it?

Magento with a team is a machine. Magento without one is an expensive problem. Wix with nobody technical works fine; WordPress with nobody looking after it collects plugins until it stops loading.

And a fourth almost nobody asks: how much does it cost to leave?

Migrating platforms is one of the jobs where most traffic gets lost if it's done badly. Choosing with only the entry in mind gets expensive if you have to move in three years. If you're already there, migrations are one of the things we do most.

The platforms we work with

We also work on other platforms. If yours isn't listed, tell us: what changes is the specific technical debt, not how we work.

FAQS

Frequently asked questions about SEO by platform

  • None in the abstract. WordPress gives you the most technical control and Shopify solves more out of the box, but every mature platform ranks. What changes is what you have to fix on each one and how much ceiling you have in highly competitive niches.

  • Not any more. That reputation comes from when it used Flash and hashbang URLs. Today it has server-side rendering, per-page control of metadata and indexation, structured data and a redirect manager. The real limit is that being a closed platform you don't control the code or how the page is served, and that caps fine-grained performance in heavily contested sectors.

  • Almost never on its own. A badly executed migration loses more traffic than any technical improvement gains. Switching makes sense when the platform genuinely holds you back (the catalogue won't scale, performance can't be fixed) and with a serious plan behind it.

  • It depends on the debt you're carrying. Fixing canonicals or redirects shows in weeks. Recovering authority split across duplicate URLs for years takes months.

Want to talk about your project?

30 minutes. No commitment. We'll tell you transparently what to expect from SEO done right.

Request free diagnosis

No commitment.